Stories about Testing God (Giving)
Indianapolis First Friends Quaker Meeting
Jason White
November 8, 2026
“Bring all the tithes into the storehouse so there will be enough food in my Temple. If you do,” says the Lord of Heaven’s Armies, “I will open the windows of heaven for you. I will pour out a blessing so great you won’t have enough room to take it in! Try it! Put me to the test!”
- Malachi 3:10 NLT
I am not a pastor or theologian. As a son of a Quaker pastor, I have lived around sermon notes my whole life and heard some sermons from my dad time and time again, but I will not stand up here and try to preach or tell anyone what scripture is saying.
Through my relationship with my wife, Abby, who is an actor and writer, and my work as a physician, I have come to understand that stories are the common currency and language of humanity, and I think they allow us to teach and share with each other, across the divides of our individual experiences.
Today, I want to share some stories of my experiences, as well as those of my family, which I hope speak to you all and help you understand how I have seen the truth of today’s scripture lived out in our modern lives.
I will start with a story of Abby and myself, and one which I am sure many here can connect to; it is a story of difficult financial decisions, a story about major life change, and about anxiety of whether or not one’s needs will be met.
The timing is just as I was finishing my four years of medical school. Through med school we lived mainly off my student loans; though Abby worked as a barista at that time, I could not (despite my efforts, but that is a different story) work and attend medical school at the same time.
We had been able to afford rent for a one-bedroom apartment near the downtown school of medicine campus, which had allowed me to walk to class and we cut more costs by going down to one car. I would walk or bike to most of my clinical rotations, and that apartment complex had been a wonderful place to live during those years.
However, I matched for residency to Community East Hospital over on the east side of town, far too far to bike from our current living space (I made a heroic effort for one med school rotation, but that is also another story).
Resident physicians do get paid, though not much, and while we knew we would have an income soon, it would be several months away (there is a gap of a couple of months between the end of med school and when you actually first start getting paid for work as a resident physician) and loans do not cover this cost of living for this period of your life).
While we were making current ends meet, we could not set aside anything for a down payment for a new place to live when we needed to move, and we were sure that with price increases the need to move somewhere closer to my new residency program, we were looking at monthly budget increases we could not afford at that time.
I am going to leave past-Jason and past-Abby there for a little while; we’ll come back to them before too long. I want to highlight our verse, which you just heard read, and go further back to explain why at this point in our lives, I was anxious but not afraid; as I had seen this verse lived out my whole life by my parents.
I will now be sharing some stories where I was present, but which are fully mine to tell, as I was only a child or teen when they occurred and I can’t recall all the important details. I witnessed my parents living this truth, but to best convey their stories, I asked my Dad to tell some of these, and I will aim to use his words as much as I can.
My sister and I saw Mom and Dad live giving of their time, service, and finances every day, and we saw it as a normal and routine part of life. In my Dad’s own words:
“In Azalia we put a check in the offering plate after I got paid the first time. We always gave 10%. Anyway, [the clerk of Finance] called and asked what she was supposed to do with the check and we said put it in the general fund. She said [that meeting] had never had a pastor do that before, something [another long-time member of the church] told me was true. But I felt it was important to practice what I preach.”
Growing up my sister and I were aware of how our family’s finances were always tight, but that God always seemed to ensure we had what we needed: food, housing, even braces for both Sarah and me. I understood that giving as my parents did was a conscious decision they made, and they have cited it many times over the years as God blessed our family.
My dad also normalized talking openly about stewardship and about church finances. I recall he would give a short sermon serious about giving every 1-2 years, and despite being, in his own words “no expert in church finances”, he was able to use his training in theology (specifically “implicit theology and explicit theology—and the need to get them in alignment”; again, his words, though I am not sure what any of that means), to help the meeting work on balancing the church budget.
Again, I will let my dad tell the story: “The church [we were serving at the time] had a history of spending more than it took in, and then going without a pastor for a year to get caught up. They came to me and said, “We are out of money.” I said, “that is too bad because I am not ready to leave.” They asked me to help them fix the situation.
“It took prayer and study and some investigation, but I finally found the root of the problem: there was a couple from the church on a mission field in Central America, and more people were actually supporting them than supporting the general fund. The missions’ money was routed through the church books, but more people gave to that than gave to the operating budget of the church.”
“I told them the answer was to put the missionaries on the budget, and encourage people to make a pledge to the budget. This met with major resistance. People felt like missions was a personal thing. Theologically that is false, because Jesus gave the Great Commission to the church, not to individuals.”
“I felt like it was important to get the whole church on board with supporting both [the missionary couple] on the mission field AND support the budget. I felt like we needed to get people to commit to the whole deal and not pick and choose.”
“Looking back, my trial sermon there was on the Great Commission. I had never connected this before, now, but I believe the Holy Spirit was preparing me for the task ahead as I ministered there. There were people who did not want the missions on the budget, because that meant everyone was supporting them. My response was that, this was the idea. This is part of the Great Commission.”
“With some resistance, the church put the missionary couple on the budget and asked people to make annual pledges to the budget. The pledges fell about 7% short of our goal, but the church decided to go for it anyway.”
“The result was the church budget [grew] 15% larger than the previous year, and income for that year exceeded the budget by another 15%. We went from $2,400 in the bank to $24,000 in one year; and put a new roof on the church and re-paved the parking lot. One of the men in the congregation came into my office that next year and said, “I was skeptical of this, but you did know what you were talking about.” The significance of that was that this man who told me this was the missionary’s father.”
Watching all those years growing up, seeing example after example of how my parents lived out Malachi 3:10 changed how my sister and I lived our lives, and then led to changes in our new household once Abby and I joined our lives to each other as well.
We did not have much true income during our early marriage years, but we would tithe on what we did, giving and trusting God would provide what we needed. This lead to ongoing living signs that God was meeting our needs, throughout our lives in that small one-bedroom apartment during medical school. And this also brings us back to our first story, when past-Jason and past-Abby, fresh out of the med school year, are trying to figure out the next stage of their lives.
During that period of time, I was getting acquainted to my new residency program and I attended a social mixer for the new incoming residents to meet the existing residents. During that mixer, one of the current residents at the program, Seth, happened to hear us mentioning our apartment hunting situation and gave us the card for their realtor, Tommy. He strongly urged us to contact Tommy, and this felt like a God moment, though I was not sure why we needed a realtor to help us navigate finding a new apartment.
Tommy was a wonderful person, warm and welcoming, and though we felt out of place, we soon learned he understood our situation better even than we did. He worked nearly exclusively with resident physicians and other young professionals, and he had a lot of experience with physicians at this stage of life. We met with him thinking it would be about getting help finding apartments, how to make the financials work out and ways to start saving for a house someday down the road.
However, he advised us we could likely get a house, and he could help us through the process. We would be closer to the hospital I would be working at, so I could walk to work when working there, and we would have plenty more room compared to the one-bedroom apartment we were used to up till then.
This sounded too good to be true, but we prayed and continued to feel that God was making this move for us, so we kept working with him.
In the span of a few short weeks, he had us looking at houses and when we walked into the one we eventually chose, we felt at peace; it needed some love (and it has continued to need love, this has been a learning house), but this has been a wonderful place to make a home and start our family.
We met with a bank and discovered that where we could be paying hundreds more monthly rent for a slightly larger apartment, we instead could pay roughly the same amount we had for our one-bedroom apartment as a mortgage payment for a whole house to live in.
I cannot fully convey in words how much this whole process touched our hearts and showed us how God provides when you as willing to test him, as he calls on us to do. To this day, I still feel that this house was a blessing and I am so thankful for it.
Abby expresses herself in art, and she made a painting around this time, using 2 Cor 9:8 as the inspiration for it: “And God will generously provide all you need. Then you will always have everything you need and plenty left over to share with others”. That painting hangs in our stairwell, so we see every day and it serves as a regular reminder of how much of a blessing this house is for us and how we can share our blessing with others.
So, I close now not with some profound theological truth, or any command or charge, but instead an invitation. I have shared these stories with you all, so I invite you all to share your stories with each other. I have seen the blessings overflow from testing God has he commands, so I invite you to join me in testing God, and see how he blesses you, your families, our community, and our meeting.
Queries:
1) What stories about how God is moving in my life can I share with others?
2) Where am I testing God, as he commands, and how is he blessing me?
3) Where am I being called by God to testing him and give in new or deeper ways?