No Mercy?
Indianapolis First Friends Quaker Meeting
Pastor Bob Henry
November 15, 2026
Good morning, Friends, and welcome to Light Reflections. The scripture I have chosen to support my message is from Matthew 3:19 from the New Revised Standard Version.
Go and learn what this means, ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’ For I have not come to call the righteous but sinners.”
In the passage leading up to the scripture that was just read, we see Jesus sitting at a table, sharing a meal with tax collectors and sinners. The Pharisees—the religious authorities of the day—are troubled. They look at the scene and see a violation of religious purity. They ask, “Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?”
Jesus overhears them and responds with a profound truth:
“It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick.”
And then he challenges them to go deeper, pointing them back to the Hebrew Scriptures, quoting the prophet Hosea:
“Go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’”
As Friends, this speaks directly to our understanding of the Light Within—that of God in every person. Jesus did not see a room full of outcasts to be avoided; he saw individuals holding the divine spark, people worthy of love, connection, and restoration.
The Pharisees wanted "sacrifice." They wanted adherence to outward rules, strict boundaries, and religious perfection.
But Jesus demanded mercy—a deep, visceral compassion that moves us to cross boundaries, break down walls, and sit at the table with those whom society has cast aside.
It is easy to speak of mercy in the abstract, but our human nature often craves the exact opposite. We love a system of strict rules, penalties, and triumphs—especially when we are the ones winning.
To illustrate this, the past couple weeks, my family has been playing a new card game with a paradoxically brutal name: Uno: Show ‘em 'No Mercy'. We have always been an Uno family, but this took it to another level.
For those who haven't played it, this version of the classic Uno game strips away all pretense of gentleness. Instead, the rules are designed to be ruthless. There are cards that force you to draw ten cards at once. There is a "stacking" rule, where one player's misfortune multiplies and cascades down to the next person. If you accumulate too many cards in your hand, you are instantly eliminated from the game—"killed off" by the rules. Sadly, this has happened to me on several occasion.
During a game of UNO No Mercy at my parent’s home last Sunday Night, our son was holding a hand of just two cards, nearing victory. He had been having his grandmother and brother picking lots of cards on both sides of him as part of us plan to win. I sensed an opportunity to change it up since I had a lot of cards, so I played a “0 “ card which had all of us passing our hands of cards to the person on the left. But the retaliation then began. My wife played a Draw 2 card. My dad added to the stack with a Draw 4, and my mom added a Draw 10, all the way back to our son thinking he was going to be getting an Uno just moments before. By the strict, unyielding letter of the law, our son with his new hand of cards was forced to draw 16 cards, instantly knocking him out of the game. That is “No Mercy.”
The room erupted. There was a fleeting, triumphant joy in seeing our son, who was about to go out, and also was making everyone draw cards, get what was coming to him. The rules of No Mercy had been perfectly, flawlessly executed.
But as we sat there looking at the massive, unplayable stack of cards in our son’s hand, a quiet shift occurred in the room. The game was over for our son and he shuffled into the other room to play with my parent’s dog. He was now excluded from the circle of play. In our desire to execute the game's law to its absolute limit, we had destroyed the community at the table.
This is the trap of "sacrifice" and rigid law. When we live by a code of No Mercy, we might win the argument, we might enforce the rules perfectly, and we might get the satisfaction of seeing our opponents get what they "deserve."
But the result is always isolation, division, and an empty table.
Early Friends, including George Fox and Margaret Fell, understood this distinction intimately. They looked at the religious landscape of 17th-century England and saw a massive machine of "sacrifice"—steeplehouses, paid clergy, elaborate sacraments, and rigid doctrines—that often operated with an undercurrent of "no mercy" for those who didn't fit the mold. They recognized that it is terrifyingly easy to substitute religious busyness and legalism for actual faithfulness.
I think we need to ask ourselves, today, what are the "sacrifices" we offer that get in the way of mercy?
Is it our desire to be intellectually, right?
Is it our comfort within the quiet walls of our meetinghouses?
Is it a passive commitment to peace that avoids the messy work of active reconciliation?
Jesus tells us that God is not impressed by our beautiful testimonies or SPICES if they remain only on paper.
The Inner Light does not call us to a cloistered perfection or a rigid enforcement of who is "in" and who is "out." It calls us into the world.
Mercy is the active, outward expression of our inward experience of the Divine.
Let me repeat that: Mercy is the active, outward expression of our inward experience of the Divine.
For Quakers, mercy is closely tied to our testimony of Equality. Mercy is not a top-down act of charity. It is not a wealthy or "righteous" person looking down on someone less fortunate and handing them a crumb.
True mercy is an act of solidarity. When Jesus sat at that table with the tax collectors, he didn't lecture them or enforce a spiritual penalty.
He ate with them.
He listened to them.
He leveled the playing field.
He looked at a world playing by the rules of "No Mercy" and flipped the table completely.
When we extend mercy, we are acknowledging that we, too, are in need of it.
We recognize that the flaws, wounds, and brokenness we see in others are mirrored in ourselves.
Mercy is the realization that we are all walking each other home, guided by the same Light.
It requires us to lay down our spiritual pride, step away from the desire to score points, and listen to the promptings of Love in our hearts.
How do we "go and learn what this means" in our lives today?
First, it means practicing mercy toward ourselves.
You and I cannot pour from an empty cup. If we carry a spirit of harsh judgment and perfectionism toward our own shortcomings—if we treat our own souls with "no mercy"—we will inevitably project that onto others. We must let the Tender Spirit quiet our inner critics.
Second, it means extending mercy within our meeting and community.
We live in a deeply polarized world, a culture of quick judgment and instant elimination. As Friends, our business meetings, our worship, and our fellowship must be counter-cultural.
When we disagree, when someone speaks out of turn, or when tension arises, our first response must not be to "stack penalties" or shut them out. Our first response must be mercy. We must seek to understand before we seek to be understood.
Finally, it means letting mercy drive our social action.
Our testimonies of Peace, Simplicity, and Justice are dead letters without mercy. When we advocate to end the death penalty, when we work at the food pantry, when we join in solidarity with those detained by ICE, we are not just doing "good work"—we are answering the divine call to choose mercy over the rigid, punitive structures of a world obsessed with winning and losing. The late John Lewis called this “good trouble.”
Friends, Jesus's invitation is ongoing. It is not a lesson we learn once and master. Every day, in every interaction, we are being asked to choose between sacrifice and mercy. Between a world of No Mercy and a kingdom of grace. Between building walls and pulling up a chair to the table.
Let us now sink deep into the silence of waiting worship, together, letting the Spirit search our hearts. Ask yourself,
· Where is God calling me to lay down "sacrifice"?
· To whom is the Light prompting me to extend a deeper, more radical mercy, today?